For a few years now (2014/2015/2016) I have made super simple gifts with alphabet stamps. It's a way to have them still be homemade, but homemade pretty quickly.
The alphabet stamps I picked were pretty big and weren't going to work for the bunch of small gifts I had to wrap, so I used my typewriter, circle punch, and some patterned paper for those.
And, although last year I made tags that teased him, this year Sean got simple, small cards in envelopes sealed with a little washing tape.